We Recommend

Links
Products
My Family Doctor Blog
10 Nutrition and Food Safety Myths, Facts and Rumors

Heard any of these? Know if they're true? Check out our experts' answers and see if your beliefs match up.

5 NUTRITION AND DIGESTION RUMORS

CLAIM: "Soda leeches calcium from your bones."
TRUE OR FALSE?
Who knows?

Much played up in the popular press, there has never been any definitive proof that the plentiful amount of phosphorus or caffeine found in sodas harms bones. What is certain is that when soda replaces calcium-rich beverages, such as fortified juice or milk, calcium deficiency can result, increasing the risk of osteoporosis.Bareuther

CLAIM: "It’s best to eat fruit on an empty stomach."
TRUE OR FALSE? Who knows?

This rumor seems based on traditional Indian diet principals and has made its way into American popular culture through various diet fads that advocate nonmixing of foods, from concern regarding putrification of such mixed foods in the stomach. (I see stomachs daily and have never found putrification of contents). In a review of scientific studies, I didn’t find any evidence-based support. If eating fruit apart from other foods makes you feel healthier, I have no objection—as long as you eat 2 cups daily!Raymond

CLAIM: "Milk products are bad for an upset stomach."
TRUE OR FALSE? True

Milk’s high protein and high fat slow stomach emptying—not a great thing if you’re nauseated. But this applies to any food that takes a while to digest. Milk gets singled out because in some people, a bug that causes vomiting and diarrhea may also cause a temporary lactase deficiency (the enzyme you need to digest milk) in the small intestines, which does not help with the diarrhea.

Besides, ever clean up curdled milk vomit?Raymond

CLAIM: "Too much cheese can make you constipated."
TRUE OR FALSE? True

But … cheese always gets an unfair rap when constipation is the topic. It’s the lack of fiber if you consume a whole wad of cheese, and not something specific to cheese, that causes the trouble. Try eating it with whole-grain Triscuits and crudités (cut raw vegetables), and you should be fine. —Raymond

CLAIM: "The more sugar you eat, the more you crave."
TRUE OR FALSE? True

Eating sweets quickly raises the level of the feel-good brain chemical serotonin. You keep eating sugar to keep that serotonin level from falling—or combat it when it does.

To avoid this roller coaster, choose complex carbohydrates (rice, pasta, baked potatoes, whole-grain bread, whole-grain crackers), which will induce a more even serotonin production.Bareuther


THE EXPERTS

Carol M. Bareuther, R.D. Registered dietitian with 25 years of experience, St. Thomas, Virgin Islands.

Eva F. Briggs, M.D. Board-certified family physician in Marcellus, N.Y.; author of the medical legal thriller Crystal Crazy.

Carol L. Kornmehl, M.D. Board-certified radiation oncologist, St. Mary’s Passaic Hospital, New Jersey; author, The Best News About Radiation Therapy.

Patricia Raymond, M.D., F.A.C.P., F.A.C.G. Board-certified gastroenterologist, Simply Screening, Chesapeake, Va.; author, Colonoscopy: It’ll Crack U Up!; assistant professor of clinical internal medicine, Eastern Virginia Medical School.

Newsletter

Last updated and/or approved: January 2010. Bios current as of summer 2007.
Original article appeared in summer 2007 print magazine.


YOU MIGHT ALSO BE INTERESTED IN:

Comments (0)add comment

Write comment
smaller | bigger
 

busy
 
© My Family Doctor 2010.
Magazine Publishing Website Design and Digital Magazine Media Solutions for Publishers